In a stunning Scottish by-election shock, Labour snatched the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse seat from the SNP, defying predictions of a nationalist victory. The result, overshadowed by Reform UK’s surge and a toxic racism row, signals seismic shifts in Scotland’s political landscape just a year before Holyrood elections.
Breaking Down the By-Election Result
Labour candidate Davy Russell secured 31.6% of the vote, narrowly edging out the SNP’s 29.4% in this Scottish by-election shock. Overturning betting odds that predicted an SNP landslide, Russell declared his win a rejection of Nigel Farage’s “poison,” emphasizing: “We don’t want your division here.” Meanwhile, Reform UK captured 26.1%—a tectonic shift from its 0.2% showing in 2021. Pollster John Curtice called this the “real story,” noting Reform’s anti-immigration platform gained unprecedented traction in Scotland despite its English nationalist associations.
The Racism Controversy That Rocked the Campaign
The campaign turned toxic when Reform circulated an edited video falsely claiming Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar would “prioritise” Pakistanis. Sarwar, of Pakistani heritage, condemned the blatantly racist tactic, with SNP leader John Swinney joining critics. Analysts suggest Reform’s strategy backfired by galvanizing Labour support. Voters rallied behind Sarwar, transforming this Scottish by-election shock into a referendum on tolerance. Labour’s internal data showed a 12% late swing in key wards after Farage’s visit.
Implications for Scottish Devolution
While Keir Starmer hailed the win, Curtice warned Labour’s vote share has “declined significantly” since 2023. The party’s devolution powers agenda—covering healthcare and education—now faces scrutiny amid waning enthusiasm. Reform’s third-place finish proves its UK poll surge (where it now leads nationally) extends to Scotland. With Holyrood elections looming in 2026, Farage aims to exploit discontent over tax hikes and immigration.
What This Means for Scotland’s Political Future
The SNP’s loss of a safe seat exposes fractures in its independence strategy. Former minister Alex Neil warned: “Voters see constitutional battles as secondary to crumbling public services.” Despite the Scottish by-election shock, Labour trails SNP by 8 points in Holyrood polling. Starmer must reconcile centrist policies with Scottish voters’ left-leaning expectations on welfare and taxation. Reform’s surge threatens to split unionist votes, ironically aiding SNP dominance. Yet its anti-EU rhetoric struggles in pro-European Scotland, suggesting its ceiling may be lower than in England.
This Scottish by-election shock delivered Labour a symbolic win but exposed systemic vulnerabilities. As Reform rewrites Scotland’s political rules and the SNP regroups, Starmer’s team faces a sobering truth: one victory won’t reverse their national decline. With 2026’s election battle lines drawn, Scotland’s era of stable majorities may be ending.
READ: UK Disposable Vape Ban Unlikely to Curb Teen Use, Experts Say
